http link to this page
ecoglobe site overview | site index | ge clear overview | ge chances | ge freeze | nz organic 2000
[yinyang] ecoglobe:     Democracy, choice, ethics & genetic engineering
Good governance, democracy and consumer choice. [further issues]
Basic concepts Democracy (a) a system of government by the whole population, usually through elected representatives (b) a nation so governed (c) any organisation governed on democratic principles [ref: dc1]
Governance the act or manner of governing [ref: dc1]
Democratic Choice "Where's the democracy in this, when a tiny subset of society imposes the GE technology upon everyone else and the common environment? Government authorities, scientists, and industry lobby groups appear to be working hand in hand to push genetic engineering application without public consent." (a citizen)
Choice and diversity GE-Biotechnology
A technology does not arrive as an act of God or a manifestation of nature; it is produced by purposeful human actions and decisions (like where to direct research moneys). Biotech does not exist (and would not exist) apart from the corporate monopolies. It is a technology prdicated on an ideology of control and power. it is a liberal pipedream, in my view, to believe that somehow we can have a decentralized, community based genetic engineering--mainly because for that (anarchist) revolution to have occurred would mean that people would want to live more in harmony with nature not in mastery. In other words, it's all a question of values. genetic engineering embodies values which are not my values. I celebrate diversity, not uniformity and monoculture (either of plants of human communities). [Phil Bereano, email 18AUG99]
Human genes in animals Transgenic Sheep
Question: How was 10,000 sheep regarded as a TRIAL only? ERMA says they are not approving commercial releases, but it seems this is exactly what PPL are now saying that they are doing?
[ecoNews item: "Transgenic sheep demand right to vote"]
Transgenic and engineered animals "Someone phoned me a few weeks ago. He'd seen the transgenic sheep at Mangakino and he said "I've been a farmer all my life. And those animals don't look like sheep. Even my young daughter could see that."
I haven't seen them myself. But I would like to ask the question, where is it all going to end? If we are going to mix species, including human beings, just because it's technically possible, or because there seems to be a profit to it, where is it going to end? Are we going to fill the NZ countryside with monsters?
I saw a picture recently of the result of GE research in Japan. It was a chicken with a third leg growing from the end of its wing. Now it might be convenient for the chicken meat industry to produce a chook with any half a dozen drumsticks, but where is it going to end?"
Clive, 23 March 1999.
Also see:
ge-clear: Genetic engineering for better health?
ecoData: Human birth defects and genetic engineering
[ecoNews item: "Chicken with four drumsticks"]
[ecoNews item: "Transgenic sheep demand right to vote"]
... ... further arguments ...
... This page is under construction. Everybody is invited to contribute to its contents. Email
Technological issues:
| GE Biotech basics | Biosafety | Food safety | Murphy's Law |
Socio-economic issues:
| Democracy, choice, ethics & morality | Better health | Feeding the world | Trade issues | "progress" & "sustainability" |
Summary of Arguments   |   ge clear site overview
Kindly let us know your arguments, opinion or critique. [top]
Pages hosted by ecoglobe: GE CHANCES GE FREEZE NZ Organics 2000
Copyright © 1999 ecology discovery foundation new zealand (charitable trust),
P.O. Box 24184, Wellington, New Zealand. ® ecoglobe is a registered trade mark.
Telephone: ++64 - 4 - 3843269, Fax: ++64 - 4 - 3898922.
email welcome@ecoglobe.org.nz
URL of this page: http://www.ecoglobe.org.nz/geclear/demchoic.htm (2APR99/Lu)
ecoglobe - for better answers
links: at the top of this page