Genetic engineering researchers and proponents frequently claim that
their research has the potential of finding cures for genetic defects.
One recent example is related to the genetic engineering of
chicken wings, desribed in the following press release:
"
Wings become legs
The engineered limbs lost feathers and grew claws.
US scientists have genetically-engineered chickens to grow basic
"legs" instead of wings.
Researchers at Harvard Medical School in Boston, Massachusetts,
took a gene normally found only in
chicken legs and transferred it to the forming wings of chick embryos.
The resulting structures lost many of their wing characteristics
and gained those of a leg.
Feathers vanished, the beginnings of clawed fingers appeared at the
end of limbs, and muscles usually confined to the leg could
clearly be seen.
The scientists believe the work may eventually help us to
understand how legs and
arms develop in humans, raising the possibility - one day -
of preventing or correcting deformities.
The research team focussed their study on a gene called Pitx1.
It is one of three genes thought to play a
primary role in determining the identity of upper and lower limbs.
A virus was used to deliver the gene into the budding wings of
the developing chick embryos.
The researchers found that it switched on another gene, Tbx4, normally
activated only in the leg.
Two other "leg" genes, HoxC10 and HoxC11, believed to play a secondary
role in limb development, were also triggered.
But Pitx1 had no effect on the gene Tbx5 that normally controls the
development of the wing. This would explain why the new "legs"
still retained
some of the features usually seen in wings.
The scientists believe the study will help us understand how
vertebrate limbs acquire their identity.
All three of the genes thought to play such crucial roles in
the development of limbs are also present in mice.
In humans, mutations in one of the genes are associated with a
condition called Holt-Oram syndrome, which produces truncated forearms.
By understanding the developmental processes at the molecular level, the
researchers hope science can eventually prevent such problems occurring.
"It is important for us to understand something about normal
leg development
because in the human we know that there are a large number of
congenital defects which lead to
incorrect limb formation," lead researcher Dr Malcolm Logan said.
"So by better understanding these genes which play central roles
in normal limb formation, we will have
a much better understanding of what's going wrong in human
congenital defects.
"And by having a better understanding of what's going wrong,
we can then think about possible
interventions to correct those defects."
The results of the US study are reported in the journal Science.
As yet unpublished Japanese research is purported to have achieved
an almost complete transformation
from wing to leg and from leg to wing.
[Transcript from a press release from the Harvard Medical School
in Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America, 1999.
Reprinted for scientific reasons only.]
ecoglobe's assessment [2 April 1999]:
The press release says that "the
researchers hope science can eventually prevent such problems
occurring".
Prevention will require both
the early diagnosis and the remedial technology.
Diagnosis would require genetic testing of the parents or, at the
latest, the embryo in the uterus at a very early stage
of its development.
The gene technology must then allow to change the genetic structure
of the parents' semen and/or ovum before fertilisation, or of
the embryonal cells very early in utero.
Given the ethical questions and socio-economic questions that
already surround prenatal diagnosis of other, more frequent
birth defects, one may question the "wisdom" and the motives
behind this research.
Also see:
Health and genetic engineering
|
Ethics of genetic engineering